The most effective brands aren’t always the cleverest; they can be the ones whose creativity improves consumer understanding while not complicating it. A brewery looking to carve out a distinct place in a crowded market can often find themselves navigating a delicate line between clever storytelling with clear communication. The challenge is making sure creativity never obscures what the beer actually is.
“Your audience needs to be able to trust that what they’re buying will taste how it’s described and maintain the highest quality,” said Kristin Marshall, the Marketing Director for Urban South.
Marshall noted that clarity doesn’t have to come at the expense of personality. A standard “Variety Pack” becomes a “Weekend Pack,” she explained, giving consumers a simple narrative cue. But she added that they’ve learned not to overcomplicate things.
“We’ve found that calling a beer exactly what it is can sometimes sell it better than overthinking a long name and flowery description,” she said.
Union Craft Brewing’s creative team, Chris Attenborough and Jenna Dutton, said storytelling works best when it invites curiosity without sacrificing accessibility. They pointed to a collaboration for the Charm City Bluegrass Festival as an example of going a bit too far.
“We named the beer ‘When I Say Charm, You Saison.’ It was clever, but way too long and ultimately lost on consumers,” they said.
Jack Dyer of Topa Topa Brewing admitted that creativity occasionally overshoots the mark.
“We have made a few incredible beers for special releases over the years where the naming and/or can art didn’t translate to the consumer,” he said, adding that confusion tends to crop up when the name itself isn’t immediately clear on a menu board or can.
At 4 Noses Brewing, Marketing Director Dustin Ramey said the brewery embraced experimentation early, releasing nearly 35 products in its first 18 months with flexible labeling to learn what resonated. That data-driven approach helped define the brewery’s core lineup before eventually leading to a full rebrand.
Over time, Ramey said the brewery leaned into an identity centered on adventure, which is now interpreted broadly and inclusively.
“Adventure, to us, is not necessarily fly fishing or river rafting. It can be sitting in a park and knitting,” he said.
Distinctive branding works when it strengthens the consumer’s ability to immediately understand, trust and use the product. Creativity, narrative, and personality are valuable, but only as a consumer can sharpen recognition.
Breweries can talk about creativity as a driving force behind their branding, but some of their most important decisions have come from shelving ideas they personally loved. The hard part, of course, is knowing when a concept fits the long game and when it doesn’t.
Grant Pauly, founder of 3 Sheeps, shared that he had to let go of an early slogan that meant a great deal internally but failed to connect with customers.
“We used the slogan of ‘Brewed with Heart & Science.’ I loved that, and it really did speak to what we were trying to do,” he said.
But customers didn’t understand what the phrase represented.
“We learned that what guides us internally does not need to be expressed in the same words when talking to our customers,” Pauly said. The sentiment stayed, but the messaging shifted to something clearer.
At 3 Daughters, VP of Marketing Brian Horne said the brewery misjudged one of its now-strongest sellers. Their Florida Orange IPA debuted simply as Orange IPA, which landed flat. Even with real Florida oranges, the name didn’t resonate and the brand stalled. The team renamed it, reformulated the beer slightly and embraced a bold, playful label featuring an alligator in a Hawaiian shirt.
“It was the most outrageous thing,” Horne said. “And now the damn thing now is our second best seller.”
The process took years of tweaking, he added, but reinforced a larger lesson: iterate quickly, fail quickly and build the portfolio around what truly works.
Marshall said Urban South recently pulled back on a THC beverage called Stratus because shifting laws stripped the product of its intended identity.
“It was intended to be a high-dose beverage, but local laws prohibited us from following through, so it lost its edge,” she said. Rebranding is underway, guided by what the market will allow and what customers are actually seeking. Marshall said the experience underscored the need to track environmental changes closely and study both consumer signals and competitor strategies.
For Union Craft, the decision to drop a beloved idea carried a warning about irreversibility.
“Once a brand leaves your portfolio, bringing it back is almost impossible; the road back is untraveled,” Attenborough and Dutton said in an email.
Short-term excitement, they said, can’t justify long-term misalignment.
Dyer echoed that sentiment in describing why the brewery pulled back from a seltzer release. “We created a product with great packaging and decided to continue to make it but to leave it in our taprooms only,” he said. The experience reinforced the importance of leaning into the brewery’s core strengths.
Killing a good idea isn’t easy, but sometimes it’s the clearest path to maintaining a brand that holds up over time.
Branding decisions often come down to a single question: who is this really for? For some, the answer becomes clearer only after they’ve stopped trying to please everyone and started speaking directly to the people who naturally respond to their identity.
For Old Nation and Short’s, the work of refining that focus has shaped everything from product development to packaging to where they choose to sell beer.
Old Nation owner Travis Fritts said the foundation of his company’s approach came from advice he initially brushed off.
“Somebody told me, ‘You just need to find your tribe and you’ll be fine,’” he said. At the time, he was simply trying to “sell some beer and pay some paychecks,” and the sentiment felt unhelpful. But once he began interacting directly with an area craft beer group — people who brewed at home, argued online and cared deeply about the process — he recognized the gap between the way he saw beer as a longtime brewer and the way passionate drinkers experienced it.
READ MORE: Find New Customers Through Unique Marketing & Branding Strategies
He said conversations with those consumers reminded him of why he got into beer in the first place.
“I was that guy. I am that guy,” he said. By engaging with them honestly, inviting their feedback and showing his own curiosity, he found a way to align Old Nation with the people who connected naturally with its values.
For Fritts, he said he learned a brewery’s brand isn’t something imposed from above; “you can sort of develop it, you can synthesize it,” he said, only after seeing where genuine enthusiasm meets credibility.
Short’s Brand and Marketing Director Christa Brenner said her team faces a different but equally delicate challenge: translating a distinctly Northern Michigan identity into something that still resonates regionally.
The brewery’s sense of place as a quirky, outdoorsy, and slightly offbeat brand is inseparable from its overall identity.
“The whole reason that we exist up here is because of where we’re at,” she said, noting that the deeper cultural cues baked into their imagery can be harder for drinkers in other states to immediately grasp.
As the brewery expanded beyond Michigan, the team treated packaging like a billboard, boiling down their messaging into a handful of clear cues that work on a shelf no matter where the beer is sold.
“Clean, crisp, refreshing, crushable,” Brenner said, explaining how they condensed the personality of their flagship Lager, ‘Short’s Local,’ into quick, accessible descriptors.
Other brands lean harder into the brewery’s playful side, using bright artwork and a sense of “adventure and a joyful lifestyle” that carries their northern Michigan energy into new markets.
Brenner said the brewery is selective about where and how it shows up outside its home region. The goal is not ubiquity. Instead, sales teams focus on a small number of accounts that align naturally with Short’s identity, reinforcing the idea that a strong brand is built through relationships rather than distribution breadth.
“We’re not trying to be in every single bar,” she said, emphasizing the importance of depth over coverage.
Creating a distinct identity in your brewery’s branding and positioning is less about style and more about discipline.
Successful branding isn’t an exercise in artistic indulgence or in chasing whatever might momentarily stand out on a crowded shelf. It’s a long-term practice of listening, refining and sometimes walking away from ideas that simply don’t serve the drinker.
A brewery that thrives is the one willing to do the unglamorous work: being clear, being consistent and being honest about who they are and who they’re for.
Be the first to comment